Nantuckets Restaurant

0 miles
Open Now
Hours 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Sunday 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Wednesday 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Thursday 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Friday 4:00 pm - 9:30 pm
  • Saturday 4:00 pm - 9:30 pm
For the area's finest dining experience, you've just found it. Located in quiet Fenwick Island, we're 5 minutes south of Bethany Beach, Delaware or 5 blocks north of Ocean City, Maryland on Route 1, Beach Highway.

Nantuckets is well known for serving the highest quality seafood straight from the docks, "dry aged" steaks, lamb, "the best crab cakes", wonderful wines and a professional staff. Take a look at our menu. Your best dining at the beach is only a reservation away!

Super Deals

$15 Off Your Check

$15 Off Your Check

Recent Reviews

Nantuckets Restaurant
a moser : 3 on 9/27/2026 1:17 am
With the cancellation of Oceans Calling, everywhere was packed. We were able to get table so decided to try Nantuckets. I was a little disappointed.
The service was wonderful. The hostess was very nice and our waiter was very attentive and friendly.
We got the Crab and Artichoke dip appetizer to start. It came out hot but just tasted like lemon. We didn't add any of the lemon that came with it. There was no crab or artichoke flavor and the toast was over done. I ordered the Lobster Mac n cheese appetizer for my meal and it was delicious. Seasoned perfect and the temperature was spot on.
My friends fish however was under cooked and cold so sent it back. Her asparagus side was supposed to be a double side order but was very small and not seasoned at all. When her fish came back out, it was cooked but rubbery and very bland.
All in all it was a pleasant atmosphere and everyone was friendly but our meal was mostly disappointing.
3 5
Nantuckets Restaurant
Estefani Marie : 5 on 6/1/2026 3:23 am
We are visiting from Long Island and decided to try Nantucket while in Fenwick Island. We had such a great experience!

We were dining with our 8-month-old son, and Suzi was absolutely wonderful. She made us feel welcome from the moment we sat down and was so accommodating throughout our meal. The restaurant was also very accommodating with our stroller, which any parent can appreciate.

The food was excellent. We ordered the quahog chowder, lobster mac & cheese, NY strip, fish du jour, and margaritas, and everything was delicious. Not one complaint from anyone at the table.

It’s not always easy going out to dinner with a baby, but the staff made it stress-free and enjoyable. Thank you, Suzi, and the entire Nantucket team for a great meal and great service. We will definitely stop back the next time we’re in the area!
5 5
Nantuckets Restaurant
Ardeshir Tabrizi : 1 on 9/6/2026 1:50 am
Tonight, my girlfriend and I decided to eat at Nantucket’s before heading home tomorrow.

The service was fine. Nothing over the top, but it was good and I really have no complaints there.

The food, however, is another story.

I am genuinely baffled by some of the reviews I’ve read. Maybe we caught them on a terrible night, but this was nowhere close to what I would expect from a restaurant charging these prices.

The bread was okay, but the butter was rock hard and basically impossible to spread. We ordered a half dozen oysters, which were fine, but the mignonette was awful. The onions were huge and barely chopped. Maybe they were supposed to be pickled red onions, I’m honestly not sure.

The Caesar salad was terrible. It genuinely tasted like bottled Ken’s Caesar dressing.

Now for the main event: the steak.

Goodness, this was bad.

I ordered my steak medium rare, yet a large portion of it was well done. The menu even makes a point about not accepting well-done requests, which made it even more ironic that half of my steak came out that way.

But I can get over a steak being cooked incorrectly if it at least tastes good.

This had ZERO flavor.

You can even see it in the photo. It looked like there was no salt, no pepper, no seasoning whatsoever. I was fighting for my life trying to cut through parts of it. I eventually had to ask for A1 sauce, which I almost never do with a steak, and I still couldn’t finish it.

The sides weren’t any better. The mashed potatoes had a film over the top like they had been sitting out for an hour, and the asparagus had absolutely no flavor and tasted like it came straight from a frozen bag.

After tip, I paid about $220 for dinner.

That is ultimately my issue. If you are going to charge fine-dining prices, the quality of the food needs to reflect it. At this price point, properly cooked meat, good ingredients, seasoning, and attention to detail should be the bare minimum.

I’m not trying to be a snob. I simply expect to get what I’m paying for, and this meal came nowhere close.

Service was perfectly fine, but the food was honestly a 0/10 for me. Hopefully management takes feedback like this seriously because there is a lot that needs to be corrected.
1 5
Nantuckets Restaurant

Specials

Daily Happy Hour Specials at Nantuckets Restaurant

4:00 pm - 6:00 pm
Cheers!
Join us for Happy Hour Daily
from 4 pm to 6 pm, Wednesday to Sunday

Reservations available 

 

More Info Remind Me

Wine Wednesday Special at Nantuckets Restaurant

4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
Wine Lover's Wednesday:
  • $10 Off All Bottles Of Wine 
 
* Reservations Suggested
More Info Remind Me

$29 Entree Specials at Nantuckets Restaurant

4:00 pm - 9:00 pm

Tonight's Off-Season Dinner Special:

  • $29 Special Entrée Selections 


Reservations Recommended

More Info Remind Me